Social Media Extinction Events
A few weeks back I was scrolling on facebook
in lieu of being human. My reward for this was an even less human piece of coding trying to entice me to the exciting world of Meta AI. In its story tabs it started showing me preview images it could compose of the cast of Backwood Folk in a sort of stop motion style. I can’t deny there are parts of my brain in the lizard corner that would love to see that, but I’m trying to be more human these days. And frankly the uninvited nature of it gave me those common fears of the modern world making choices for us. So I let the unprompted preview image sit there unshared and unposted. Meta AI would make another stab, previewing the lead of my sci-fi Webcomic, Tourist Unknown, as manga. Just as before I was mildly annoyed but successfully put it back in the part of my brain where I keep all the other red flags of modern life.
Its last ditch effort was to start putting pictures of my wife in tight silver retro jumpsuits right out of Barbarella. After that I downloaded a plug-in for my browser and erased every post, reaction, and tag of the last twenty years. I followed that up wiping every Instagram post I’d ever had. It was a near instantaneous reaction as earlier in that week, another social media app I’d long since ditched had turned its AI client into a xerox for revenge porn and more.
I’ve mentioned before that I was a long time internet creature. We were early adopters of dial-up in the rural Ozarks, and I very quickly discovered forums. I was a little terror on them in the kind of way that a 14 year old boy on the internet would be in that era. Rose tinted glasses make me want to say it was a better web then and in some ways it was. I don’t think my activities even rank in the kind of trouble a 14 year old boy in the internet could get into on the internet now. But these issues were baked in from the start, there just was less internet then. My main stomping grounds on the internet at that point were nuked from orbit in 2005. That’s its own story, and one I sometimes see “internet archivists” try to piece together from time to time. I’ll leave that be for now, save that it really revealed to me what the modern internet would be, including its reocurring theme of women as being seen as a resource for male posters. Just at a far smaller scale. The forum collapse did remove my internet history -and rather unfortunately for myself- a lot of my social outlets.

It wouldn’t take long for the internet to give me a new home. In 2006, I’d be able to use a college e-mail I’d obtained at a summer camp to get on facebook. I felt impossibly grown-up in my rural school to be the only one on the computer with the cool kids in college. It was also crucially how I kept friendships running from those summer camps all the way up to including some of those campers in my bridal party. When I made it and joined all the cool kids in college facebook served completely in its purpose as digital campus hub. Events pages and groups made sure I knew what was going on away from my screen and when to get there. It was a fun place to hang, but more crucially it was a fun place to tell you where to hang.
The plug-in I used to clear my social media more or less had to run for three days to delete everything. I wasn’t just online for an Ozarker, I was very online. That was clear watching it go through every post. It was a little like a tv airing my entire adult life where I’d stroll past my office and see the episode where I passed my driving exam, that one that was my first week of college, early relationships and song lyrics after early relationships. I saw posts of my dreams and aspirations, I saw myself achieve some of those dreams and aspirations. In truth, it was a little cathartic watching a sad lonely boy develop into someone he hoped to become. For a brief moment I regretted I was destroying all these moments. But that’s because it was just me and a computer screen and the evaporation of my last twenty years.
Another sense came to mind as my life flashed before my eyes. These little posts were hardly revealing in isolation, but in their accumulation? I saw something deeply private given away to everyone I’ve ever known, and a lot more I’ve never met. I truly had ascribed the entirety of my life to a platform. 20 years I’d given ownership to people who mean us all ill intent.
Late last year there was a small kerfuffle in Fayetteville, Arkansas over a Christmas Parade. A local bar owner appeared as a Krampus. This wasn’t particularly out of course for Fayetteville. I’ve done Christmas Markets for years in the region. And almost every single one included some presence of the horned Christmas goat man. Plenty even had folks running around in Krampus costumes and committing mischief. If there’d ever been a single issue it certainly didn’t make the news. So I was a little surprised when 2025 provided a crusade. Right wing influencers seized on it stating it as proof of satanism taking over our region.





In 2017, during the first Trump Administration, I’d do little charity portrait drives. I didn’t really know what I was doing, just mad at the state of things and wanting to help. I’ve never been good at yelling at people in the correct way to get the results I want so I drew pictures. It was a decent success, and I’d do more occasionally. Trying to focus more on local charities (or at least local chapters with something like Planned Parenthood) I was purposefully uncombative with as little grandstanding on my calls for portraits as possible. I wanted to invite people to help where I could, I was better at that than condemnation.
After awhile I’d intermix for profit portrait drives around Halloween. I used these to fund a lot of Tourist Unknown’s print editions. You’d get to pick your own horror theme and I’d draw you in costume. The Halloween Drives proved meteoric, and I’d had have to start earlier and earlier to make sure I got to everyone in who was interested. A lot of books got printed on those portraits, even if I fear they outshined most of my other artistic output at the time. It’s still how people introduce me locally. “Oh this is Gus, you know those little cartoon profiles? He does them.”

Turning back to 2025 an enterprising influencer proved I’m right to be suspicious of anyone with digital creator in their job description. Old Halloween portaits I had drawn of the bar owner had been brought forward as proof of his satanist past. He’d be already been hit with hatemail and ridicule for a few weeks, and digging into his social media was naturally the next event. Luckily, I didn’t really experience any turmoil from the controversy. Rightwing influencers aren’t very good at the research part so he attributed the drawing to Bo Counts, the bar owner who had been in the Krampus costume. For what it’s worth I’ve known Bo for years and even was a brief co-host on his then radio show, now podcast, on film. We are both painfully into movies, and his portrait was not portraying him as the devil but Darkness from the film Legend. A subtle distinction I grant, but I think it’s an important one. It demonstrates that there is a point where we are taking seriously the fears of people performatively cowering at a character from a movie about unicorns.
It wasn’t lost on me that most of the complaints came from the nebulous online and rarely from locals who had actually attended the parade. Just folks whipped up from other places to stop “the enemy” or I suppose “the adversary.” Online with little aspirations of community but plenty for targeting. It’s impossible to presume good faith in an attention economy where content creators gin up controversy for their brand. Add a moral element and you can justify the time spent to yourself. It’s a tale as old as time dating back further than the town square or the fire. What’s new is the algorithmic push to make every ranting town loony read authoritatively.
I quit doing the portrait drives a few years back. Over the course of five years I drew over 1300 people and pets. Mostly of folks from Northwest Arkansas. Every drive I’d leave with a sense of fulfillment and hands that wouldn’t stop shaking for a solid week. Even still, I’m not sure if it was the increasing physical limitations that got me to stop doing them. I attribute a lot more to the sinking feeling of seeing those drawn portraits turn into AI ones in recent years. Slicker and quicker than I can compete with. Which, I’m not actually sure a portrait drive would do any differently financially in the post-AI world, but it cratered any interest I had. The appeal the portrait drives held was a true feeling that I was part of my community. I drew neighbors developing families, friends getting a couples portrait with a new partner every year, weird requests from local eccentrics and the like. There was a lot of human texture in the background of those portrait drives. But that’s not what online wants to show us, it wants to show us polish and no pores. No thumbprints in sculptures but way too many fingers. It doesn’t matter that it’s sloppy or wrong or antagonizing if it happens right now and gestures at having sheen. I think about the amount of revisions I’ve done a little resentfully these days. Especially when they came from folks with the laziest error ridden generated images in their profiles now.
That internet building off the blocks of social media born from Harvard’s Hot or Not feels impossible to avoid now. Immediate satisfaction with a heavy dose of the thrill of cruelty abstracted enough to compartmentalize. But you won’t hear the influencers complain about that as long as these platforms favor them. Everyone now just conspires with website mechanics as a cudgel against perceived enemies. They wear the same kayfabe of protecting children, but with the new wrinkle of utilizing websites that will undress them at the click of a button. But there’s no utilities in pointing out hypocrisy in America as it’s a country founded on it. They’re just further obstacles.
Was it stupid to look for our better angels on the new social media sites? Probably. But in my defense I was in high school when I arrived. Though, I don’t have that excuse anymore. Neither do a lot of us, and I must presume we all feel that tension. So I did what previous families did with their memories. I packaged them up in a little hard drive for the closet, the millennial scrap book, where I can visit them for the rest of my life.
My facebook and instagram sit there strictly for business now. Little digital tombstones for dates and releases required of my job. Those 20 years are safely in my memories (and in my closet) and no longer for the consumption of strangers or the material for their machines.
I can socialize offline. Hope to see you there.
who woulda known the big bad wolf was imaginary and the house we build out of social media is the true culprit. i’d like to shut things down as well not wanting to be replicated in that way. anyhow thank you for being good people gustav. hope the skies clear to where we can all meet up again. but currently wearing my rain coat.
Lovely to hear from you, Kim. I think they’ll clear in time, but those storms are rough today. Best wishes to you.
Following suit soon! Thanks for the inspo!
Hell yeah!